Crushing Debt or Savvy Strategy? Financial Literacy and Student Perceptions of their Student Loan Debt

Authors
Markle, G.
Publication year
2019
Citation Title
Crushing debt or savvy strategy? Financial literacy and student perceptions of their student loan debt.
Journal Name
Journal of Student Financial Aid
Journal Volume
49
Issue Number
1
Page Numbers
1-20
DOI
https://ir.library.louisville.edu/jsfa/vol49/iss1/4
Summary
Student debt is a serious concern among many American college students. This study examined the influence of financial literacy on college students’ perception of loan debt and their college financial decision and education related behavior. The findings indicate that financial literacy and loan awareness have implications on their education-related behavior and perceptions related to student debts.
Key Findings
Parents were the most frequently cited source of advice regarding college students’ loans (56.4%), followed by college admission staff (16.8%), and then, online sources (9.2%).

Students with lower levels of financial literacy and student loan awareness tended to perceive their debt negatively; however, students with higher levels of financial literacy and student loan awareness tended to perceive their debt positively.
Negative perceptions of student debt were related to adverse management strategies like not buying required textbooks, decreasing credit hours in order to work, not taking summer classes, not declaring a minor, and increasing credit hours to graduate sooner.
College students who had higher scores on financial literacy and student loan awareness tended to belong to higher household incomes.
Implications for Military Professionals
Help develop modules to assist eligible students apply for financial assistance programs

Collaborate with social services professionals in the field to facilitate programs that provide support to college students who struggle to manage education loans
Implications for Program Leaders
Provide workshops to help students learn about available community resources for financing their college education
Disseminate information regarding the common types problems youth face due to students loans and where youth and their families can find help for those problems
Implications for Policy Makers
Encourage collaboration among educational institutions and community-based organizations to support youth who have specialized needs (e.g., students of low SES families, first-generation college students etc.)
Recommend education of professionals (e.g., mental health and education professionals) on the possible effect of students’ loan on their academic performance and psychological well-being
Methods
Data were collected from 429 college students enrolled in a public university located in northwest Georgia through a survey.

Participants self-reported on measures that assessed financial literacy, student loan awareness, debt-related questions and eight open-ended questions relating to money-related decisions and concerns.
Data were analyzed to examine relationships between financial literacy, student loan awareness and textual date generated from the open- ended questions.
Participants
Fifty five percent of the participants were female, and approximately 77% of participants belonged to the age range 18-24 years.
In the sample, about 35% of participants had no student loan debt.
Among the sample, about 66% of participants were White, about 14% were Asian American, about 9% were Latino, and about 7% were Black.
Limitations
The sample consisted of college students from one university in the U.S., which limits the generalizability of the results.

The study used a cross-sectional design, which limits any conclusion of long-term impact of student loan on education-related behavior and psychological well-being.
Subjective measures were used to assess student loan awareness, which can introduced unintended bias in responses, especially in the absence of objective measures.
Avenues for Future Research
Collect data from college students across more time points to obtain more accurate patterns between student loans and education-related behaviors

Assess loan awareness and education-related behavior with more objective measures (e.g., college grades, a quiz about student loans) rather than only self-report items
Investigate if student loan management varies with improvement in financial literacy
Design Rating
3 Stars - There are few flaws in the study design or research sample. The flaws that are present are minor and have no effect on the ability to draw conclusions from the data.
Methods Rating
2 Stars - There are no significant biases or deficits in the way the variables in the study are defined or measures and conclusions are appropriately drawn from the analyses performed.
Limitations Rating
2 Stars - There are a few factors that limit the ability to extend the results to an entire population, but the results can be extended to most of the population.
Focus
Civilian
Target Population
Population Focus
Abstract
Almost three quarters of American college students use loans to fund their college education, although according to public discourse student debt is a critical problem. Grounded in social reproduction theory and consumer socialization theory this study examines the influence of financial literacy on students’ college financing decisions, perceptions of student loan debt, and education-related behavior. A sample of 429 undergraduate students selected using systematic cluster sampling from a large public university in the southeast completed a survey containing closed and open-ended questions. Participants reported moderate levels of financial literacy (72.3%) and student loan awareness (62.7%). Only 20% of students in this sample used estimated college expenses to determine how much to borrow. Students with higher levels of financial literacy were more likely to view their student loan debt positively as a financial strategy, were less concerned about their ability to repay their loans and made better financing and education-related decisions compared to students with lower levels of financial literacy. Students with lower levels of financial literacy were more likely to make counterproductive decisions. Student loans are an increasingly necessary strategy for educational attainment; their effective utilization requires a level of financial literacy which most students do not possess.
Attach