Women in the National Guard: Experiences With Children During Deployment

Authors
Nilsson, J. Berkel, L. Kelly, P. J. Trummer, M. Maung, J. Sukumaran, N.
Publication year
2015
Citation Title
Women in the National Guard: Experiences with children during deployment.
Journal Name
Counseling Psychology Quarterly
Journal Volume
28
Issue Number
2
Page Numbers
113-131
DOI
10.1080/09515080.2014.970127
Summary
Female National Guard members who had children and had been deployed overseas completed interviews about their experience during reintegration. Mothers reported concerns for their children’s well-being prior to deployment. Some mothers reported strong, negative reactions from their children during reintegration.
Key Findings
Participants worried about their children before and during their deployment.
Prior to deployment, deciding who would care for children was especially stressful.
The majority of women felt a sense of loss due to not being able to participate in important family events during deployment, such as birthdays and holidays.
Children’s responses to deployment and reintegration varied, including some strong negative reactions to their mothers’ return.
Implications for Program Leaders
Develop curricula focused on helping parents prepare children for deployment (e.g., how to ask family and friends for help, talking with children about what to expect)
Implement support groups specifically for mothers preparing for or returning from deployment
Provide courses for family members and friends caring for children during deployment focusing on recognizing problem behaviors in children and identifying community resources
Implications for Policy Makers
Recommend collaboration between the Department of Defense and community-based organizations to provide support to deploying mothers
Suggest professional development for community providers about how to support mothers post-deployment and their children
Continue to provide infrastructure and support for Family Readiness Groups and other supports for Service members with children
Methods
Participants were recruited via word of mouth, flyers posted at National Guard units, and announcements on units’ Facebook pages.
Participants completed semi-structured interviews about post-deployment family reintegration experiences.
Interview questions focused on women’s experiences of reintegration, children’s reactions to deployment, and stressors experienced across the deployment cycle.
Participants
Female National Guard members (N = 30) who had deployed outside the U.S. and had children participated.
Participants had an average age of 39 years (SD = 10.5); 37% married, 43% divorced, 10% engaged or partnered.
Over two-thirds (77%) had deployed once, 20% deployed twice, and 3% deployed three times.
Over one-third (37%) had one child, 30% had two children, 33% had three or more children.
Limitations
Recruitment primarily occurred through National Guard websites and Facebook; findings may be biased towards women who frequently use the Internet.
Women were recruited from Midwestern states; results may not generalize to all female National Guard members living outside the Midwest.
All data were retrospective and collected via self-report, both of which may introduce biases.
Avenues for Future Research
Employ longitudinal designs to examine mothers’ experiences across the deployment cycle
Include data from both female National Guard members and their children
Compare mothers’ and fathers’ parenting experiences during the deployment cycle
Design Rating
2 Stars - There are some flaws in the study design or research sample, but those flaws do not significantly threaten the ability to make conclusions based on the data.
Methods Rating
3 Stars - The definitions and measurement of variables is done thoroughly and without any bias and conclusions are drawn directly from the analyses performed.
Limitations Rating
2 Stars - There are a few factors that limit the ability to extend the results to an entire population, but the results can be extended to most of the population.
Focus
Coast Guard
Target Population
Population Focus
Military Branch
Military Component
Abstract
More women of the National Guard and Reserves have deployed to combat zones overseas than ever before. Upon reintegration, these soldiers often face a number of stressors related to their combat zone experiences and readjustment to civilian life. One of these stressors is the reintegration with family, partners, and children. This qualitative study involved interviews with 30 women from the National Guard regarding their reintegration experiences with their children. Four categories were revealed from the data: (a) Concerns for Children’s Well-being, (b) Sense of Loss (c) Reintegration: Personal Challenges, and (d) Reintegration: Children’s Reactions. Implications for clinical work with returning soldiers and further research are discussed.
Attach