National Guard Service Members Returning Home After Deployment: The Case for Increased Community Support

Authors
Blow, A. MacInnes, M. D. Hamel, J. Ames, B. Onaga, E. Holtrop, K. Gorman, L. Smith, S.
Publication year
2012
Citation Title
National Guard service members returning home after deployment: The case for increased community support.
Journal Name
Administrative Policy and Mental Health
Journal Volume
39
Issue Number
5
Page Numbers
383-393
DOI
10.1007/s10488-011-0356-x
Summary
Michigan residents were surveyed via telephone about their support for National Guard members and programs to support their reintegration. Many residents report knowing a National Guard member, being supportive of multiple services to support these Service members, and being willing to pay an additional tax for these services.
Key Findings
Twenty-nine percent of participants knew a National Guard member who had deployed to a combat zone.
Ninety-seven percent did not support deploying both parents at the same time, and 69% did not think that single parents should be deployed at all.
Fifty-nine percent reported that the federal government should be responsible for supporting National Guard members upon homecoming from deployment.
Over 80% of respondents supported tax dollars paying for all medical and rehabilitative services for National Guard members who sustained a physical or emotional injury.
Implications for Program Leaders
Disseminate information regarding community employment assistance programs available to National Guard members to increase awareness of their programs and services
Offer education in community centers about the unique experiences of National Guard personnel and their families and how community members can be supportive
Provide specialized services for families in which both parents deploy simultaneously
Implications for Policy Makers
Continue to support collaboration between the DoD and employment assistance, community mental health, and medical care facilities to develop programs to meet the unique needs of returning National Guard members
Encourage professional development workshops for community healthcare personnel about the distinct challenges and needs of National Guard personnel and their families
Recommend that single military personnel be provided sufficient notice prior to deployment to be able to make arrangements for childcare during their absence.
Methods
A statewide random survey was conducted in Michigan in 2008 through random digit dialing telephone interviews.
Interviews averaged 27 minutes in length.
Interviews assessed perceptions of the needs of Michigan National Guard members and opinions regarding the support that should be provided to military families.
Participants
Nine hundred fifty-three Michigan adults participated.
Data were weighted to make results representative of the general Michigan population.
No additional demographic information was reported.
Limitations
Very little demographic data were presented making it difficult to know how these participants compare to other residents.
No participation rate was specified making it difficult to assess interest in participation; it may be that those who participated were more interested in military issues and could bias the results.
The survey instruments used were not described in detail, making relipcation of the current study difficult.
Avenues for Future Research
Conduct this research nationally to see if these attitudes are similar or different in sites beyond Michigan
Assess the level of tax that residents would be willing to pay to support these changes
Examine what returning Service members and families deem helpful from community members during the reintegration process
Design Rating
2 Stars - There are some flaws in the study design or research sample, but those flaws do not significantly threaten the ability to make conclusions based on the data.
Methods Rating
2 Stars - There are no significant biases or deficits in the way the variables in the study are defined or measures and conclusions are appropriately drawn from the analyses performed.
Limitations Rating
2 Stars - There are a few factors that limit the ability to extend the results to an entire population, but the results can be extended to most of the population.
Focus
Multiple Branches
Target Population
Population Focus
Military Branch
Military Component
Abstract
National Guard service members and their families face unique circumstances that distinguish them from other branches of the military. In this article, we highlight unique National Guard needs and argue that more can be done by policy makers to help this population. We present the findings from a representative survey of Michigan citizens showing that public support exists for increased assistance for these service members. Using the multiple streams framework, we propose that policy makers currently have the opportunity to facilitate increased support for National Guard members and families. Specifically we suggest policy implications that feature the important role of state and local resources. National Guard service members and their families face unique circumstances that distinguish them from other branches of the military. In this article, we highlight unique National Guard needs and argue that more can be done by policy makers to help this population. We present the findings from a representative survey of Michigan citizens showing that public support exists for increased assistance for these service members. Using the multiple streams framework, we propose that policy makers currently have the opportunity to facilitate increased support for National Guard members and families. Specifically we suggest policy implications that feature the important role of state and local resources.
Attach