Attitudes of Military Personnel Toward Homosexuals

Authors
Estrada, A. X. Weiss, D. J.
Publication year
1999
Citation Title
Attitudes of military personnel toward homosexuals.
Journal Name
Journal of Homosexuality
Journal Volume
37
Issue Number
4
Page Numbers
83-97
DOI
10.1300/J082v37n04_05
Summary
Seventy-two male Reservist Marines were surveyed to examine Marine attitudes toward lesbians and gay men. The role of various demographic variables in predicting attitudes toward homosexual was examined. The Marines’ attitudes toward lesbians and gay men in general were mildly negative, but their attitudes toward gays in the military were somewhat more negative.
Key Findings
The Marines’ attitudes toward lesbians and gay men were mildly unfavorable; attitudes were more negative toward gay men compared to lesbians.
Marines with more negative attitudes were more likely to have had no contact with a gay or lesbian person than those expressing less negative attitudes.
More negative attitudes toward lesbians and gay men were significantly correlated with conservative political ideology and greater religious attendance.
Implications for Program Leaders
Provide classes to gay men and lesbians in the military to help them cope with possible discrimination and microaggressions they may encounter from others who possess negative attitudes toward sexual minority Service members
Offer information in their staff training about the challenges faced by some sexual minority Service members when confronted with discriminatory behavior
Educate service providers about the resources available to help sexual minority military personnel
Implications for Policy Makers
Promote awareness campaigns on military installations regarding the necessity of treating all Service members and families, including those who are sexual minorities, with respect and dignity
Continue to support programs that provide help to gay men and lesbians in the military
Encourage collaboration between DoD and community-based programs that offer support to sexual minority Service members to provide confidential and streamlined service
Methods
With permission of the unit commander, participants were recruited during a regular workday.
Marines completed measures of attitudes toward lesbian and gay men and attitudes toward homosexuals in the military.
Mean scores were calculated and correlations were run with demographic variables.
Participants
The sample consisted of 72 male Marine Reservists all from the same unit in Southern California.
Participants’ mean length of military service was 4.20 years.
Mean age = 23.4 years; 78% were single, 14% married.
Nighty-four percent had a high school diploma, 77% some college, 4% college degree.
Limitations
The sample consists of primarily Latino, only male Reservist Marines in Southern California; the results may not generalize beyond this sample.
The scores on the self-report measures were not compared to established norms; therefore it is unknown how these attitudes compare to other military or civilian samples.
The measures of political ideology, contact with gay people and religious attendance were not explained.
Avenues for Future Research
Replicate this study with a larger sample, including members of other military units, officers, and females
Examine possible changes in attitudes over time in the wake of the repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell”
Explore how the repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” influences Service members’ operational readiness
Design Rating
1 Star - There are some significant flaws in the study design or research sample such that conclusions drawn from the data are suspect.
Methods Rating
2 Stars - There are no significant biases or deficits in the way the variables in the study are defined or measures and conclusions are appropriately drawn from the analyses performed.
Limitations Rating
1 Star - There are several factors that limit the ability to extend the results to a population and therefore the results can only be extended to a very specific subset of the population.
Focus
Marines
Target Population
Population Focus
Military Branch
Military Component
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to assess attitudes of enlisted military personnel with regard to homosexuality. Seventy-two male members of the Marine Corps Reserve responded to a questionnaire exploring attitudes toward lesbians and gay men and attitudes toward homosexuals in the military. Results showed that attitudes with respect to these topics were mildly unfavorable. In addition, several predictor variables employed in similar studies with civilians were examined. Correlational evidence showed that participants expressing more negative attitudes tended to have more conservative political ideology, reported more religious attendance, and were more likely to have had no contact with a gay or lesbian person than those expressing less negative attitudes. These findings suggest that the attitudes held by enlisted military personnel are similar to those of their civilian counterparts.
Attach